The Kookie Jar LI specializes in stuffed, ooey, gooey cookies. Our flavors usually rotate on a weekly basis, but our most popular flavors are always available.
We offer pick up in Commack, NY or local delivery within 15 miles. You can place an order on the "Shop" tab or message us for more information. If we are sold out, unfortunately we cannot take additional orders until we restock.
PLEASE NOTE FOR DELIVERIES: If no one is home at time of delivery, we will happily leave the order outside your door. We are not responsible for any lost or stolen packages, animals getting into boxes and/or damage that may occur once the box is left at the door. Thank you for understanding!
Baked Fresh To Order
Our classic chocolate chip cookie.
MILK & COOKIES
Our chocolate chip cookie base mixed, stuffed, and topped with Oreos.
Our chocolate chip cookie base stuffed and topped with Italian Rainbow Cookies and rolled in chocolate sprinkles.
COFFEE & DONUTS
Our chocolate chip cookie base mixed with espresso chips and topped and stuffed with chocolate glazed donuts.
Our chocolate chip cookie base mixed and rolled in sprinkles.
Our chocolate chip cookie base mixed with graham crackers, stuffed with marshmallows, and topped with a chocolate bar. Our take on a delicious s'mores!
Ever dream of eating your favorite PB&J sandwich in cookie form? Now you can! This scrumptious chocolate chip cookie base is filled with creamy peanut butter and raspberry jelly to really take you back to your childhood.
If you can't ever decide on a flavor, this cookie is for you! This cookie features our famous chocolate chip cookie base stuffed with an Oreo, rolled in sprinkles and topped with a peanut butter cup.
Our double chocolate chip cookie base mixed with white chocolate chips, Oreo chunks, and stuffed with an Oreo.
PEANUT BUTTER CUP
Our chocolate chip cookie base mixed with peanut butter, stuffed with a peanut butter cup and rolled in Reeses Pieces.
THE COOKIE DONUT
Our chocolate chip cookie base rolled in cinnamon sugar and stuffed and topped with a powdered donut.
Our double chocolate chip cookie base mixed with semi sweet and white chocolate chips.
If you're a fan of coconut, this cookie is for you! This cookie features an almond and coconut base mixed with semi-sweet and white chocolate chips and stuffed with an Almond Joy.
CINNAMON BUN SWIRL
This cookie features a white chocolate cinnamon base mixed with chunks of cinnamon rolls (made from scratch!) and rolled in cinnamon sugar.
HOT COCOA PEPPERMINT
Winter is here! This hot cocoa base is mixed with white chocolate chips, stuffed with a marshmallow and topped with crushed peppermint.
Baked Fresh To Order
This gooey skillet has chunks of brownies (made from scratch!), semi-sweet and chunk chocolate chips, topped with more brownie chunks. This is the chocolate lovers dream.
Our popular cookies in skillet form! These gooey, delicious 8-inch pies are ideal for any party, family gathering and more. They serve about 5-8 people depending on how you slice it. These can also be customized with your topping of choice!
This 8-inch skillet is filled with chunks of Italian Rainbow Cookies, chocolate chips and chunks, and then topped with more rainbow cookies. Feeds 8+ depending on slices.
PEANUT BUTTER PIE
This skillet is swirled with peanut butter, chocolate chunks and topped with mini peanut butter cups and Reese's Pieces.